Job Stealer, Spot Stealer, Dream Stealer: an outlook on
Affirmative Action from an FGLI, minority college student
In the twenties, while some enjoyed their fortunes and lavish
lifestyles, others discovered that the American Dream extended
beyond financial success and entailed social and self-acceptance.
Even the rich discovered the American Dream was unattainable.
Their sentiment was further strengthened in the decade to come.
In today's twenties, while some enjoy their legacy
college acceptances and generational wealth, other students
discover that people view their success as a handout in the name
of 'diversity'. And, as a result, the American Dream remains
unattainable. Our sentiment was further strengthened by the ruling
of the Supreme Court a few days ago which favored institutional
barriers and the social unacceptance of minority students in
higher education.
When I read the Great Gatsby in
eleventh grade, I learned that not all money and success were seen
as equal. I was introduced to the distinction between old money
and new money. And, my perspective on the country I lived in
changed.
I grew up a strong believer of the American
Dream. My immigrant parents have always been extremely grateful
for the life they were able to build in this foreign country. So,
they shared their American Dream with me: to see me and my sister
as college graduates. As an American-born daughter of immigrant
parents, I never doubted my ability to make their dreams come true
because this country praised fairness and opportunity for all.
However, as I grew older I
began to see past the haze of promises and 'inspirational' words
spoken by our leaders. The struggles and obstacles faced by
immigrants and their children became clearer and clearer. We are
not welcome here, and a significant number of fellow Americans
only see us as trespassers and “job stealers.” Many of our
communities continue to live in impoverished conditions, our
success limited by government policies and language barriers. In
the words of Michelle Obama, “the ground is anything but level.”
Those who do see us as the backbone of this country
perceive our role as toilet-cleaners or fieldworkers. We are
simply not considered capable of being part of the “select few”
who excel. We are viewed as the lower class necessary for the
success of other groups.
Nonetheless, I completed
eleventh grade believing that times were changing. The growth and
celebration of self-made individuals served as proof.
But, college admissions tell a different story.
I discovered the complex nature of college admissions too late. In
ninth grade I learned that good grades and academic achievement
did not suffice to compete. By tenth grade, I began pursuing more
extracurricular activities, challenging coursework, and
intellectual enrichment. I had two years to obtain commendable
test scores, engage in impressive extracurricular activities, and
discover the world mission and outlook I would provide on my
college applications. By the end of eleventh grade, with my
college admission fate practically sealed, all that was left was
to condense my life and dreams into a compelling application.
So, why did I put so much effort into getting into a
Top 10 school? For the same reason any American, minority or not,
would want to attend one: funding, research, and the opportunity
to create change.
Did I need the “affirmative action
handout”? Absolutely. While some students were writing textbooks,
I was saving up to afford them. While others were purchasing
extensive private tutoring, I was browsing the internet for free
practice SAT exams and applying for fee waivers. While others were
starting nonprofits to help their communities, I tried to embody
the change in my community by being the tutor others couldn't
afford. I needed my college admissions officer to know that though
my accomplishments were not as striking as some of my peers', they
were still my pride and joy because I was able to organically
flourish despite the adversity I faced as a minority student.
I was simply too late, too poor, and too uninformed to
compete under the same standards. My sister pursued a completely
different path in regards to college education, so I lacked a
mentor to guide me through the process. My parents had to save up
to drive me to advanced math seminars, and the closest testing
center for certain math competitions was 100 miles away. By the
time I discovered the strategies and resources that were at my
disposal, I was already a high school senior.
Many Black and Latine students come from communities where
resources are scarce and conditions are unfavorable for them to
achieve success as early as some White and Asian American
students. As a result, they cannot compete against the same
standards.
Affirmative action is not intended to discriminate
against White and Asian American students or make them pay the
price for the struggles of Black and Latino communities. Rather,
it is meant to be a bandaid on the bullet hole caused by the
historical marginalization of these minorities. Our goal is to one
day rip off the bandaid when the wound has healed. Our goal is to
someday find affirmative action unnecessary.
Like
everything, affirmative action has its pros and cons. Although it
is not entirely good, by today's conditions, it is necessary. I
will not ignore the feelings of stress it may generate in White
and Asian American students. I understand that it can be
discouraging to feel that the bar is raised higher just because of
your race. However, affirmative action is not to blame for this,
but, rather, the meritocracy system surrounding college admissions
and financial success, where spots are scarce and only a few can
excel. Affirmative action or not, class sizes are sealed and some
will be rejected, others accepted.
But, I will also
not ignore the impostor syndrome and discouragement of Black and
Latino individuals when they are labeled “spot stealers” or
“diversity recruits.” Those who choose to diminish the efforts of
students and professionals because they did not have a high degree
of achievements at a young age hold similar sentiments to those
that looked down upon new money and self-made individuals. It is
hard to be born successful when your ancestors died feeling
worthless.
As college students, we are forced to live
in a society in which the wedge between old money and new money
remains strong. It is unfortunate that society has pitted
first-generation college communities against one another when
legacy admissions enjoy their own version of affirmative action.
Maybe I needed the standards to be lowered. But,
legacy students often find the standards to be non-existent. Only
those students are capable of being born successful. And, while it
is not their fault that they were born into those families, if
society expects all students to compete on the same playing field
regardless of what their ancestors faced, they should also earn
their spot regardless of what their ancestors achieved.
Many argue that affirmative action is a form of
systemic racism. Perhaps that is true. But it seems that we need
systemic “racism” to combat the true systemic racism that minority
students face. Since the SCOTUS found that it was necessary to
defend the Constitution and ban this form of systemic racism, I
hope that they also find it urgent to combat racism in healthcare
and police brutality.
We cannot preach equality when
our communities need equity.
I feel terribly sorry for the students that are barely making
their way into higher education, and are finding out that they
can't receive the handouts in exchange for what this country has
taken away from them for centuries. Additionally, I feel for all
the students who will no longer be able to speak on how their
cultural, ethnic, and racial backgrounds have shaped their
identities and the perspectives they will bring to their
institution. To enforce “colorblind” college admissions is to
ignore a crucial part of many students' identity. Our lives and
experiences are not colorblind. And, the opportunities presented
to us aren't colorblind either.
If any student thinks
that I stole their spot at MIT, I want them to know that (though
it should not be necessary) I will do my absolute best to show the
world that I deserve and have earned my spot at my institution and
that, now more than ever, I will strive to become the leader and
the mentor that my fellow latino students deserve and need. I may
have found my voice a little later but that does not make it any
quieter.
To all other minority college students and
professionals, let's become the representation we want to see in
our communities. Let's create the equity that our government has
denied us.
Lastly, I hope that as minorities, we are
once again able to mend this wedge that the elite few have drawn
between us. I hope that we stop seeing each other as “dream
stealers" and, instead, begin seeing each other as collaborators
and fellow warriors against racism and adversity. I hope that one
day affirmative action can be a topic of the past and that the
ground is leveled.
I pray that one day there won't be
any parallels between these twenties and the 1920's. As
minorities, we can become our ancestors' American Dreams.
*Disclaimer: The following blog post is intended to provide
insights into affirmative action from the perspective of a
college student who was recently admitted into college. It is
important to note that I am not an expert on the topic, and the
information presented in this post is based solely on my own
experiences and observations, as well as those of the students
around me. I do not claim to represent the opinions or
experiences of all minority students or college applicants.
Furthermore,
it is essential to understand that my perspective may evolve
over time, and my opinions on affirmative action may change as I
gain more knowledge and understanding. The purpose of this blog
post is to foster constructive dialogue and offer a personal
viewpoint, but it should not be interpreted as an authoritative
or definitive account on the subject matter.
Readers
are encouraged to explore a variety of sources, engage in
further research, and seek out diverse perspectives to develop a
well-informed understanding of affirmative action. It is vital
to consider the complex nature of this topic and to approach
discussions with empathy, respect, and an open mind.